MODUS Blog Series: Trust, Transparency & the Urban-Rural Divide
Same Tools, Different Places: Rethinking the Urban-Rural Divide
Part Two of our three-part series on trust, transparency and the urban-rural divide.
When we start a project in small and rural communities, one question tends to come up early: what does a planning firm from Vancouver know about this place?
Here’s our answer, along with what we’ve learned about how BC’s urban and rural parts fit together.
Where does the skepticism come from?
Rural skepticism of city-based institutions runs deep in Canada. In a 2026 essay on urban-rural polarization in the Journal of Futures Studies, Greg Landry describes a rural outlook shaped by “a belief that rural voices are ignored by urban elites.” With so much of the country’s political power and media based in cities, that feeling makes sense.
There’s history behind it, too. Rural regions have often been treated as places to draw resources from (e.g. ‘source’), discharge waste (e.g. ‘sink’)... or as holding space for cities that just haven’t grown yet. Historically, little attention has been paid to what rural communities want for themselves. Political scientist Katherine Cramer has studied how that builds, over time, into a feeling that rural places don’t get their fair share of power, resources or respect.
Perhaps surprisingly, most of our work at MODUS has focused on planning in small and rural communities and regional districts. In fact, we rarely work in the City of Vancouver itself, and – very personally – many of us have deep roots in rural places. We frequently return to a central question: is the project team taking the time to understand your place and history, from the very first meeting?
Better together: urban and rural BC
The more time we spend in communities across BC, the clearer it is that urban and rural places need each other.
Rural regions are first and foremost places where its residents steward and protect our provinces’ most significant natural assets, from ecologically-rich watersheds to diverse forests and grasslands. These natural assets contribute to BC’s considerable resource industry that has powered both towns and villages across BC for millenia — from the exceptional abundance of pre-colonial Coast Salish Indigenous communities to more contemporary forestry and mining that helped found so many of the villages, towns and cities we love. It’s in rural areas where soil is tilled, farmland is cared for and our food is grown. Together these all shape a tremendously valuable tourism sector that celebrates the unique landscapes, cultures, resources and experiences BC has to offer. These are places where generation upon generation of families have and continue to live and where people who no longer care for an urban lifestyle choose to settle. One of the things we appreciate most about rural communities is the resourcefulness and “help-your neighbour” attitude: coming together to solve common challenges, both out of a preference to act without waiting for government help or approval, and out of necessity where public infrastructure is limited. We see that self-reliant spirit to be complementary to a wider region. Rural communities and their urban neighbours lean on one another every single day. In BC and Canada writ large, stewarding such expansive geographies takes people on the ground — maintaining shared infrastructure, local food systems, and working landscapes. Ensuring rural ways of life remain viable and supported is how the entire region stays resilient.
Towns and cities bring together the housing, services and jobs that support many of these economic activities. Farms, resources, and tourism need markets and workers. Cities need food, clean water and the working landscapes around them. These places function together, they are inseparable, and protecting one helps the other.
Wait, haven’t I seen this plan before?
At MODUS we aren’t shy about our biases. They’re communicated through our vision statement which is the first thing you see when you visit our website: “co-creating deep green, just and healthy communities”. So it’s no surprise we approach our work with similar tools and frameworks from one community to the next. Examples include equity and climate lenses, urban or growth containment boundaries and the transect (which we discuss later in this post). In each instance, we use these tools to:
understand and assess the communities in which we work;
inform local conversations; and,
shape our approach to seeking solutions.
Open the toolbox of any builder — whether woodframe homes, concrete and steel offices — and you’ll find a tape measure, a level, a hammer and a scribe. We all practice using ‘tools of the trade.’
Similarly — and beyond specific tools — every OCP in BC is built under the same rules as determined by the Local Government Act. Certain topics, like land use, housing needs, roads and infrastructure and climate targets are required by law, no matter the size of the community or which firm writes the plan.
What goes inside that structure is where each plan becomes its own: the vision, the priorities, the objectives and policies, the land use designations, and how they all fit together. This comes from what community members, First Nations, local government staff and elected officials tell us. A shared structure has its perks, too. Clear, consistent plans are easier for staff to use, easier for councils to rely on and easier for residents and developers to find their way around. And templates offer efficiencies, whereby standard approaches can afford more time and attention to customization of the parts that matter most.
We have early discussions with clients and communities about how they would like to structure their plans… and ongoing discussion about how to shape them. We’ve written plans that are organized by land use designations, community goals, or by topic area. We’ve written plans that organize policies by objectives, by responsibility, or by lens (e.g. climate, equity, etc.). Ultimately, it’s most important that the content and priorities shape the template, not the other way around.

The Cowichan Valley transect: a customized visualization of the various intensities of settlement across a vast region.
What even is a transect?
Lately, we’ve been testing a new way to organize policies and land use designations using a tool called the “transect”. We’re the first to admit that the transect can be misunderstood. Ecologists have long used transects to study how habitats change across a landscape. In the early 1900s, the Scottish planner Patrick Geddes sketched his “Valley Section,” showing how settlements and livelihoods shift from the hills down to the coast. Planners borrowed the idea to describe a whole region, from wilderness and farmland to villages, small towns and city centres.
Most importantly, a transect is a communication tool that supports a quick understanding of relationship and context. It provides a common language — made more accessible through locally-adapted, illustrated diagrams — so that when we talk about places that are “rural”, “urban”, “villages” and “natural” we can all point to the same thing. Words mean different things to different people, they can be culturally relative. We’ve been to public meetings where planners might use the word suburban to describe a place that a resident might call rural. If we can quickly explore context, physical places and qualities, we often find that terminology is the only disagreement. To that end, we see the transect as a most helpful point of reference – a measuring stick of sorts – to carefully explore community values and bridge our understanding of a place with that of its residents.
In that regard, the transect is a tool, not a template. It doesn’t propose or decide any land use designation on its own, it is neutral on the value or importance of its various parts, and clients and elected officials choose whether and how to use it. Where it is used, it helps consider context and relationship. It supports discussion to match the right scale and type of development in the right place. With context and logic more clearly communicated, it can make future decisions simpler and help communities better understand what to expect in the future… and maybe even why.
The transect has been comfortably received in some communities, while in others it has proven too cumbersome. We’ve heard criticism saying it is a template imposed on a community that ignores the unique characteristics of a place. While certainly not the intent, we ultimately defer to what works: the use of this tool requires both skill and care; and progress comes through shared understanding, built on the deeper foundations of trust.
Keeping the rural, rural
Once we better understand what we mean by “rural” and “urban” and agree that the two should be kept distinct (however interdependent), we recognize the role of urban (or ‘growth’) containment boundaries. Contrary to popular belief, these are not immutable. They are regularly refined based on a community’s needs: extended when a strong case for new greenfield development is made (often with specific infrastructure capacity upgrades) and tightened when there’s a planning goal to refocus development inwards and upwards.
A clear boundary helps manage growth. It keeps farmland for farming and prevents the fragmentation of precious natural assets. It helps towns evolve in more deliberate ways that are easier and less expensive to service, leading to a lower tax burden on residents who ultimately have to share the costs of building, maintaining and operating community infrastructure. Building new homes where there’s already water, sewer and transit takes pressure off rural land and the systems rural residents rely on.
That’s what we bring to regional planning, reinforcing each part of a region in doing what it does best.
Why does a good process look so messy?
For starters, planning today produces far more public information than ever before: background research, capacity modeling, risk analyses, ‘What We Heard’ reports, and recorded council debates. That transparency is healthy and we welcome this accountability in local government. As planning consultants, it also means we share in the complexity and face the hard, uncomfortable trade-offs in plain sight. Long gone are the mid-century days of Robert Moses (e.g. The Power Broker) and backroom deals where highways were drawn through neighbourhoods without public scrutiny. Today, planning is an open civic negotiation… and a far more tortured pathway ‘getting to yes.’
So if a planning process looks a bit bumpy from the outside, that can be a sign it’s working. People can witness the debate, and they can often see a record of their input. At the most recent PIBC conference this past summer in Penticton, keynote speaker (and our friend!) Uytae Lee, spoke about the need to stop sugar-coating ‘What We Heard’ reports and more effectively communicate opposition in planning projects. It was a well-received challenge to planners across the province. And, it sets us up to better explain why certain feedback is integrated into our plans and why other inputs are not.
Back in the eye of the storm…
This brings us back to the reality we outlined in part one of our blog series.
Across BC, planning for compact communities is neither a luxury, nor a ‘flavour of the day.’ It’s a logical progression and very often a physical necessity: bound by mountains, water, precious little arable farmland, and the fiscal reality of infrastructure costs, expanding outward has very real and practical limits across much of the province. To ignore these limits is to invite increasingly severe risk and consequence.
When regional needs meet local streets, the impacts are felt in a very real and deeply personal way. New housing, roads and industries in our communities change how we get around, where we spend our time and ultimately the way we live our lives. Not everyone will agree with these shifts and disagreement isn't necessarily indication that a planning process has failed. Certainly too much disagreement can be a sign of failure. It is, however, clear proof of how much people care about the places they call home while grappling to navigate their ever changing surroundings.
At MODUS, this is precisely where our work lives. We don’t avoid these tensions or pretend to sell an easy, pre-packaged process to ensure consensus. Instead, we design processes that are honest and accountable, transparent and rigorous. We help communities navigate those hard trade-offs and make (sometimes) difficult decisions together.
Up next
In our final post, we’ll look at what it takes to build trust when planning gets hard, share examples from our own work, and offer some ideas for residents, planners and local governments.
